My daughter and I were in Switzerland riding on a train at night after a dinner. The train was not patrolled or staffed by any train personnel (interesting in its own right). We were at the last stop and noticed that there was a woman’s purse left behind. We touched a button that connected us to someone with the Metro and explained the situation and asked what should we do. The reply was “leave the purse on the train and someone will return it to the owner.” As I shared this story with my fellow workers in Switzerland, they said “it is Switzerland, she will mostly likely get it back in a day with extra money in it.” I ask you, how cool is that?
Contrast that story to the recent shooting in America. My fellow citizens are able to purchase guns (pistols, rifles and shotguns) along with body armor and walk into a public place and kill people. I can’t think of an acceptable scenario where this makes any good sense. I don’t want to go “anywhere” where my family and I can be exposed to gunfire and potentially get shot. That is not the society or community that I want to be a part of. I also do not want to carry a firearm, under any circumstances. I would not feel safer bring a gun to a gunfight – I don’t want to be in a gunfight - ever in my life. I cannot even rationalize any value of a handgun outside of law enforcement and the military – any value. So I started talking to my friends about this and I was very surprised at their strong responses – maybe I am not from this planet.
The big objection is giving up part of our civil rights, specifically the rights to bear arms. So I looked up the Second Amendment and here it what it said regarding this subject, “A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.” A well regulated Militia, that does not sound like the average gun owner today in America at all – in fact, not even close. For me the trade off is safety for the society at whole, as previous stated I don’t ever want to see a gunfight. I certainly would not feel any safer if I was in a movie theater and the person next to me shot back (I would prefer the odds of making him choose versus firing back at a shooter). In the Aurora example, the shooter was in full body armor anyways. I only want a trained professional engaging the bad guy, not average Joe who has watch too much TV. Regardless, I don’t think that Second Amendment was written or developed with the intent of arming society against random attacks. So using it as an excuse to defend our civil rights does not convince me. I would rather live in a society where gun ownership is regulated to just single bolt action rifles, which would limit some of the present threat.
I am trying to understand the rational reason why one would need a gun. I came up with two:
• Hunting – you like to kill things. Even if you decide that this is a good reason to have a gun, I would ask is it a good reason to have a handgun? How about a semi-automatic? When I think of hunting, I think of hunters aiming from a distance at their target. I also think that if a hunter wants to keep and show his target or eat his target, he/she wants to keep the amount of lead and holes to a minimum, so single shot action is mostly likely acceptable. Or put differently, an AK47 is not a requirement for hunters.
• Personal Protection – if someone wants to shot and kill me, his/her odds of success will be high. I am not trained in combat, so my odds for defending myself will be low. I would not want to be shooting in my house of fear of hitting my wife and/or children. How does the police know who to protect versus who to go after if we both are firing guns? Last, shooting a target and shooting a person is an entirely different thing that I do not think people give the right consideration to. It is easy to say I will kill anyone who enters my home until you find out it is one of your kids friends.
In the end, for me, it boils down to safety and I feel safer with trained dedicated professionals defending me versus myself. I don’t think that all guns should be banned, but I do think that all semi-automatic guns should not be allowed in any public places. I don’t think more guns equal more safety; I think more guns equal more fatalities. I like the story about the purse on the Swiss train better than Aurora shooting.